Order with us today!
(309) 473-8231
Welcome to
As a family owned bakery, we use tried and true recipes, and all fresh ingredients made with love each and every day to satisfy your sweet tooth! We opened our first retail shop in January 2012 and haven’t turned off our mixers since.
More About Us
We rotate new, seasonal flavors in our retail location weekly. Our Signature Cupcakes are consistent every week, allowing us to rotate 6 different flavors weekly.
If you’re not a cupcake fan, indulge in some of our other sweet creations. We have everything from cookies to bars to pies to satisfy your cravings.
"We had a cake done for our daughters first birthday and I was blown away! The cake and smash cake were so beautiful and tasted amazing! My vision was exceeded. We also brought some cupcakes home and they were delicious! Truly can’t speak high enough for this local bakery!"
"They made me a beautiful custom cake for my mothers birthday a few months ago. They have lovely decorators and friendly staff every time I've been in here whether its for a cute mini cupcake strolling uptown with friends to a fancy cake."
"Wonderful little bakery with many gluten free options. Staff was very helpful and kind. Baked goods were amazing!"
"Some of the best cake & cupcakes I've tasted and I've had my fair share. Frosting game on point too."
"They made our wedding cake recently. Not only did it look exactly like the pictures I showed them, it tasted AMAZING!! They also had homemade healthy dog treats last time I was in there; my dog absolutely loved them."
"They helped me recreate a wedding cake for my wife and I to celebrate our one year anniversary. The cake turned out great and very tasty."
"My favorite bakery in town! Cute, quaint atmosphere, fantastic treats. Their salted caramel cupcakes are fantastic! Best I’ve ever tasted."
"We ordered a dozen mini cupcakes (Snickers, baker's choice, blueberry key lime, and strawberry to name a few) and two strawberry muffins. The muffins were very moist and flavorful as were the cupcakes. We enjoyed the cupcakes with fillings best, but all of them were excellent. Note: the lady who helped us said the cupcake flavors change regularly, so the flavors we tried may not be the same as what are available in the future."
"We have been regular customers of Sugar Mamas since it opened! Between holidays, family bdays and just for fun to get a delicious gooey bar, we have enjoyed them Year after year!! Love you Sugar Mamas!!"
"Sugar Mama’s has become my go-to bakery. The cakes are always beautiful and exceptionally delicious! I’ve ordered cool custom cakes, an incredible vegan cake, birthday cakes, and most recently a bunny cake for Easter. They are always fresh and moist cakes with lovely buttercream frosting. They NEVER disappoint! I’ve always received superb customer service! Plus they even send home directions on how to cut and serve (which I really appreciate because it’s a more effective way than I was doing it)."
"The kids and I love coming here. Everyone is so friendly, and there's not a bad thing on the menu. You won't regret giving this place a try!
"
"Sugar Mama Bakery has such a great atmosphere, and everything I've had from there has been delicious! There's always a very friendly and patient staff member ready to help when I arrive too. I love having this one-of-a-kind shop in our town. Though, my scale may beg to differ."
"Every time I go to Bloomington-Normal I stop by here for their cookie dough. It's egg free and comes in different varieties such as regular, gluten-free, vegan, vegetarian and others. The proportions seem small at first but they're perfect. The workers are friendly and polite."
"Delicious custom cakes and cupcakes. Show up at a party with a box and you'll be a star!"
